Elgin
Associated Press All-Ohio
1962/63 – Jim Cornett (AA HM)
1975/76 – Brian Agler (AA 3rd)
1978/79 – Scott Mobley (AA SM)
1980/81 – Dave Hollenbaugh (AA HM)
1983/84 – Jamie Bame (AA HM)
1991/92 – Steve Hawkins (III HM)
1993/94 – Joe Schriml (III 3rd)
1994/95 – Cort Hamilton (III HM)
1995/96 – Cort Hamilton (III 3rd)
1996/97 – Cort Hamilton (III 1st)
1996/97 – Andy Gast (III HM)
1997/98 – Andy Gast (III 3rd)
1999/00 – Josh Gast (III HM)
2000/01 – Ryan Carr (III HM)
2003/04 – Jason Marks (III SM)
2004/05 – Michael Mathey (III HM)
2005/06 – Michael Mathey (III 3rd)
2006/07 – Matt Margala (III HM)
2008/09 – Doug Ute (III HM)
2009/10 – Doug Ute (III SM)